A Canadian supplier waiting 60 or 90 days for payment from a large buyer has a liquidity problem with four established solutions. They are frequently discussed as interchangeable and they are not: they differ in what secures them, whose credit they price against, whether they create debt, and what they require of the business in return.
Choosing the wrong one is expensive in ways that are not obvious at the outset. The comparison below is organised around the questions that actually determine the answer.
Option One: Bank Operating Line
A revolving facility from a chartered bank, secured by a general security agreement over the business and priced off prime.
- Cost: The lowest of the four, by a clear margin.
- What it requires: Balance sheet strength, trading history, profitability, and ongoing compliance with financial covenants. Typically a personal guarantee from the owners of a private company.
- Balance sheet effect: Debt. It consumes borrowing capacity and appears as a liability.
- Where it fails: The limit is set against historical financials, so it does not scale with a contract won last month. It is also the facility most likely to be reduced or withdrawn when the business is under stress, because covenant breaches and lender caution arrive together.
An operating line is the right answer for an established, profitable supplier with stable volumes. It is frequently the wrong answer for one growing quickly, because the facility is sized against where the business has been rather than where it is going.
Option Two: Invoice Factoring
The supplier sells its invoices to a factor, receiving an advance of most of the face value immediately with the balance released on collection.
- Cost: Higher than a bank line, expressed as a discount fee on invoice value plus, in some structures, a service charge.
- What it requires: Creditworthy customers and clean, undisputed invoices. The supplier's own financial strength matters far less, which is why factoring is available to young and fast-growing businesses that banks decline.
- Balance sheet effect: Depends on the structure. True non-recourse factoring can remove the receivable from the balance sheet; recourse factoring generally leaves an obligation.
- Where it fails: Notification. Most factoring arrangements involve the factor notifying customers and collecting directly, which some suppliers find commercially sensitive. Concentration limits also apply, so a supplier dependent on one large customer may find only part of its ledger eligible.
The detailed comparison with asset-based lending is set out in our analysis of factoring versus asset-based lending.
Option Three: Asset-Based Lending
A revolving facility advanced against a borrowing base of eligible receivables and inventory, recalculated regularly as the collateral pool changes.
- Cost: Between a bank line and factoring.
- What it requires: Reliable reporting. Borrowing base certificates, ageing reports and periodic field examinations are standard, and the administrative burden is real.
- Balance sheet effect: Debt, secured on the collateral.
- Where it works best: Businesses with substantial receivables and inventory whose funding requirement moves with trading volume. Because the facility flexes with the collateral, it scales with growth in a way a fixed operating line does not.
- Where it fails: Thin-asset service businesses with little to pledge, and companies unable to produce the reporting the facility demands.
Option Four: Buyer-Led Early Payment
A program established by the buyer under which its suppliers can elect to be paid early on invoices the buyer has already approved, funded by a third party against the buyer's payment obligation.
- Cost: Priced against the buyer's credit rather than the supplier's. For a small supplier selling to a large or government buyer, this is frequently the cheapest capital available to it — often below what its own bank would charge.
- What it requires: That the buyer has established a program. The supplier cannot create one unilaterally.
- Balance sheet effect: In a properly structured program, no supplier debt, no lien and no restrictive covenants. The supplier is being paid early on its own approved invoice.
- Flexibility: Typically voluntary invoice by invoice, so the supplier draws only when it wants the cash and leaves the rest to settle on normal terms.
- Where it fails: It only covers invoices already approved by a participating buyer. It does nothing for pre-delivery costs, work in progress, or sales to buyers outside the program.
OAKRG's Canadian Supply Chain Performance Program operates on this basis, offering optional early payment on approved invoices to suppliers in defence, manufacturing, energy, transportation, critical minerals and food production, with buyers retaining their existing payment terms and due dates. Our overviews of early payment programs and reverse factoring explain the mechanics from both sides.
Early payment prices against your customer's credit. Every other option prices against yours. For a small supplier selling to a large buyer, that difference is the whole decision.
Choosing Between Them
A few questions resolve most cases:
Is the problem pre-delivery or post-delivery?
None of these four instruments funds costs incurred before an invoice exists. Buying materials and paying labour to fulfil an order requires purchase order or contract finance, which is a different instrument underwritten on the order itself.
Is your customer stronger than you are?
If the buyer is a government department, Crown corporation, or large investment-grade corporate, instruments that price against the buyer's credit — early payment programs, and to a degree factoring — will be cheaper than those pricing against yours.
Can you satisfy covenants, and do you want to?
Bank lines and asset-based facilities impose covenants and reporting. If compliance is uncertain, or if a breach would be triggered by exactly the growth being financed, a non-covenant instrument is worth paying more for.
Does customer notification matter?
If your customer relationships would be affected by a third party collecting your invoices, confidential invoice discounting or a buyer-led program is preferable to traditional notified factoring.
Will the facility grow with you?
A fixed operating line will be a constraint again within a year of fast growth. Instruments sized against the receivables ledger grow with the business automatically.
Combining Them
These options are not mutually exclusive, and most suppliers of scale use several deliberately: a bank operating line for baseline requirements at the lowest cost, early payment on invoices to participating large buyers, a receivables facility covering the rest of the ledger, and purchase order finance for specific large contracts. Equipment and facility investment sits outside all of it, financed on its own terms over the asset's life.
The discipline is simply to use the cheapest instrument available for each category of requirement rather than funding everything from whichever facility happens to exist. OAKRG arranges and combines these facilities for Canadian suppliers through its supply chain finance practice, with transactions typically from $1M to $100M+.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is early payment cheaper than invoice factoring?
Usually, where the buyer is stronger than the supplier. A buyer-led early payment program is funded against the buyer's approved payment obligation, so the pricing reflects the buyer's credit rather than the supplier's. For a small or mid-sized supplier selling to a government department, Crown corporation or large corporate, that is frequently cheaper than factoring and sometimes cheaper than its own bank facility. The limitation is availability: the program has to exist and the buyer has to participate, whereas factoring can be arranged by the supplier on its own initiative.
Does invoice factoring damage customer relationships?
Traditional notified factoring involves the factor informing customers and collecting directly, which some suppliers consider commercially sensitive, though in several sectors it is routine and attracts no comment at all. Where it is a concern, confidential invoice discounting leaves collection with the supplier and the customer is not notified, and buyer-led early payment programs avoid the issue entirely because the buyer established the arrangement. The right choice depends on sector norms as much as on the individual relationship.
Can a supplier use more than one working capital facility at once?
Yes, and most suppliers of any scale do, though the facilities must be structured so their security does not conflict. A typical arrangement combines a bank operating line for baseline needs at the lowest cost, early payment on invoices to participating buyers, a receivables facility across the remainder of the ledger, and purchase order finance for specific large contracts. What requires care is intercreditor arrangements: a bank holding a general security agreement will need to release or subordinate its interest in receivables financed elsewhere, and that consent should be obtained before the second facility is committed.
What funds costs incurred before an invoice is issued?
None of the four options compared here, which is the most common gap suppliers encounter. Operating lines, factoring, asset-based lending and early payment programs all depend on an existing receivable or balance sheet. Costs incurred before delivery — materials, components, labour, tooling — require purchase order or contract finance, which is advanced against a confirmed order and underwritten on the buyer's strength and the deliverability of the contract rather than on an invoice that does not yet exist.